|« Ethiopian woman missing on Gold Coast||Ethiopia Prepared to Invade Somalia »|
July 20, 2006
By Mesfin Mekonen
DLA Piper Rudnick Gray Cary, a lobbying firm that has been retained by the Meles regime for $50,000 a month – money that could be far better spent on economic development -- is circulating a document through the Ethiopian embassy in Washington, D.C. The document attempts to discredit HR 5680, the Ethiopia Freedom, Democracy, and Human Rights Advancement Act. Some of the claims in the document and responses follow. This is a brief response to some of the assertions in the DLA Piper document.
As the objective sources of information about the situation in Ethiopia provided below demonstrate, the Meles regime is a brutal dictatorship.
Contact your member of Congress. Inform them in your own words why you feel they should vote for HR 5680. Also, feel free to distribute the following document.
Claim: "The Smith/Payne bill has been in deliberation for about ten months. At the root of its genesis is the persistent lobbying on the part of a slice of the Ethiopian Diaspora organized by the extremists in the Ethiopian opposition who have persistently and flatly rejected all forms of political engagement."
Response: The legislation is based on the first hand observations of Rep. Smith and members of his staff who have visited Ethiopia. Rep. Smith and his staff have reached out to the Ethiopian community in the United States and to moderate Ethiopian politicians, civic and political groups. In addition, the legislation was informed by public testimony from prominent individuals. The Ethiopian opposition have displayed tremendous courage in their pursuit of political engagement. They have risked – and in all too many cases, lost – their lives and freedom in the pursuit of peaceful, democracy.
It is inconceivable that anyone would label U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of State Donald Yamamoto an "extremist." On March 28, 2006, in testimony about the legislation to Smith’s subcommittee, Yamamoto said "hopes for progress [in Ethiopia] have been chilled, as the government has clamped down on individuals’ right to assemble and journalists’ ability to report events." Secretary Yamamoto also noted irregularities in the elections. He reported that "The European Union report on the elections asserted that over 90% of the CUD complaints were rejected as opposed to only 30% for the ruling party. It seems clear that the CRB/CIP process did not prove an adequate means for a fair resolution of all electoral disputes."
The subcommittee also heard testimony from Lynn Fredriksson, Advocacy Director for Africa, Amnesty International USA. She stated: "Amnesty International is increasingly concerned that the Government of Ethiopia is systematically violating its citizens' most basic political freedoms. We are particularly concerned that the government and ruling Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) party have not allowed members of political opposition parties (including elected parliamentarians), human rights defenders, independent journalists and other citizens their basic human rights of speech, press, assembly and association. The security forces have committed serious human rights violations with impunity against demonstrators and political detainees. A parliamentary commission appointed by the Prime Minister to investigate shootings by security forces and violence by opposition demonstrators in June and November 2005 (when excessive force appeared to have been used by security forces) has not yet reported on these abuses and their circumstances."
On December 16, 2005 Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT) issued a strong statement about the situation in Ethiopia. Leahy, who also is not usually considered an "extremist," concluded: "The Bush Administration should make clear to Prime Minister Meles that if his government does not abide by the basic principles of democracy, due process and respect for human rights, including an end to the use of random searches, beatings, mass arrests and lethal force against peaceful protesters, and if political detainees are not released, that we will join with the European Union and suspend our aid to his government, including our support for financing from the World Bank and the African Development Bank other than for basic human needs. There should be severe consequences for such a flagrant subversion of the will of the Ethiopian people." His statement is available at http://leahy.senate.gov/press/200512/121605a.html
Similarly, the U.S. State Department is not an "extremist" organization, and it is not influenced by lobbying of Ethiopian opposition groups. Its most recent Human Rights Report on Ethiopia stated:
"After the May elections, serious human rights abuses occurred, when the opposition parties refused to accept the announced results, and in November after the Coalition for Unity and Democracy (CUD) called for civil disobedience, which resulted in widespread riots and excessive use of force by the police and military. Although there were some improvements, the government's human rights record remained poor and worsened in some areas. In the period leading up to the May national elections, campaigning was open and debates were televised. The Carter Center described this period as credible and commendable. However, in the period following the elections, authorities arbitrarily detained, beat, and killed opposition members, ethnic minorities, NGO workers, and members of the press. Authorities also imposed additional restrictions on civil liberties, including freedom of the press and freedom of assembly. The following human rights problems were reported:
. limitation on citizens' right to change their government
. unlawful killings, including alleged political killings, and beating, abuse, and mistreatment of detainees and opposition supporters by security forces
. poor prison conditions
. arbitrary arrest and detention of thousands of persons, particularly those suspected of sympathizing with or being members of the opposition
. detention of thousands without charge, and lengthy pretrial detention
. government infringement on citizens' privacy rights, and frequent refusal to follow the law regarding search warrants
. government restrictions on freedom of the press; arrest, detention, and harassment of journalists for publishing articles critical of the government; self‑censorship by journalists
. government restrictions on freedom of assembly including denial of permits, burdensome preconditions or refusal to provide assembly halls to opposition political groups, and at times use of excessive force to disperse demonstrations
. government limitations on freedom of association
. violence and societal discrimination against women, and abuse of children
. female genital mutilation (FGM)
. exploitation of children for economic and sexual purposes
. trafficking in persons
. societal discrimination against persons with disabilities, and discrimination against religious and ethnic minorities
. government interference in union activities."
2. "local groups such as the Ethiopian Human Rights Council, which appealed the decision of the National Election Board, did in fact observe the elections."
This statement, which purports to correct a factual error in the HR 5680, is in fact incorrect. According to a European Commission report: "The NEBE [National Election Board] barred a considerable number of domestic observer groups from monitoring the elections. Although this decision was later revoked by the courts, the judgment came too late to allow effective observation by these groups." More important, The European Commission report (available at http://ec.europa.eu/comm/external_relations/human_rights/eu_election_ass_observ/ethiopia/2005_final_report.pdf), concluded "Overall, therefore, the elections fell short of international principles for genuine democratic elections." The report details an election that was rendered illegitimate by massive intimidation, harassment, refusal to allow opposition campaigns access to media, and outright fraud.
3. One of the main opposition parties—the CUD—repeatedly rejected the results of the National Electoral Board, including the final and official results.
The CUD rejected the election results because they were fraudulent. As noted above, the European Commission also concluded that the election was not fair and the reported results were not accurate. The European observers "observers assessed the closing and counting processes negatively in almost half of urban polling stations observed, a very high figure for international observers to record, and even worse in rural polling stations observed…. EU observers witnessed cases that suggested serious irregularities with election results, including figures that were implausible." It is hardly surprising that the CUD rejected the results under these circumstances. Accepting them would make the CUD complicit in a fraud on the Ethiopian people.
4. On September 15 the Carter Center concluded, "[The majority of the constituency results based on the May 15 polling and tabulation are credible and reflect competitive conditions." According to the U.S. Department of State, "these elections stand out as a milestone in creating a new, more competitive multiparty political system in one of Africa's largest and most important countries."
The European Union sharply criticized the Carter Center September 15 report, and later the Carter Center documented serious election irregularities.
Secretary Yamamoto noted the following in his March 2006 testimony to Rep. Smith’s subcommittee: "The European Union report on the elections asserted that over 90% of the CUD complaints were rejected as opposed to only 30% for the ruling party. It seems clear that the CRB/CIP process did not prove an adequate means for a fair resolution of all electoral disputes.
According to the Carter Center, which monitored the election process along with the European Union, in one-third of the investigations they observed, witnesses appeared frightened or intimidated, and there was credible evidence of intimidation and harassment including beatings and briberies. It is clear that the CRB/CIP is an ad hoc mechanism to review electoral complaints, rather than a reliable process for resolving the Parliamentary seat dispute. The Carter Center recommended that in this instance, and until the NEBE gains the maturity to resolve political disagreements, the opposition refer these cases to the High Court for adjudication."
Yamamoto testified that: "Election observers noted that voters were perplexed as to why there was a re-vote and noted a dearth of information and increased presence of security forces at polling stations. Of even greater concern was the violence that erupted on June 8 and November 1, 2005 that led to the arrests of thousands of people after the elections and the detention of 128 CUD and civil society leaders. We objected strongly to the violence and the detentions both publicly through several press statements and privately to the government and the opposition. Of particular concern to the United States are the early-November arrests of much of the Coalition for Unity and Democracy (CUD) leadership, along with prominent members of civil society, journalists, editors, and publishers. After seven weeks in detention, the Ethiopian government charged 131 individuals with capital offenses of "outrages against the constitution and constitutional order," and, in several cases, "treason" and "attempted genocide." He added: "In addition to these leaders, Ethiopian authorities detained over 14,000 demonstrators holding them for as much as nine weeks in detention camps far away from Addis Ababa. While public protests aimed at destabilizing the country are objectionable, there is no excuse for mass arrests and the use of lethal force against civilians who wish to express their opposition to their government."
6. Regarding the opposition's refusal to accept seats in Parliament:
When it became clear to the Meles regime that a substantial number of opposition candidates would be elected to Parliament, Parliamentary rules were changed to rob the opposition of the right to participate in government. On contrast to democratic parliamentary governments, the opposition was stripped of the ability to debate issues, introduce legislation, or do anything other than sit silently while the government controlled the agenda. To mute the public's outrage, the Meles regime imprisoned hundreds of journalists. Refusal to accept their seats in Parliament – and their assigned roles as rubber stamps for the Meles government – led to the arrest of opposition politicians on charges of treason and genocide.
7. Claim: The U.S. must support the Ethiopian government because it is an ally in the war on terrorism.
In fact, there is broad support in Ethiopia, especially in the democratic opposition, for the U.S. and for the war on terrorism. The Ethiopian government’s repression is likely to lead to the kind of instability that breeds terrorism. The Economist noted in March 2006: "In fact, the very stability of Ethiopia could be at stake. Mr Meles has embittered the class of professional Amharas that Ethiopia relies on to get things done. And, with high unemployment, millions of urban poor, particularly in the capital, have little to lose. They were mostly the ones gunned down by the trigger-happy police in last year's street protests. Demonizing and imprisoning the politicians they voted for in the election might mean more riots, and more deaths."
Additional sources of information about the situation in Ethiopia:
The Washington Post included Meles in its list of the world’s worst dictators (April 23, 2006, page B3):
"Prime Minister, Ethiopia Zenawi was widely criticized for responding to accusations of fraud in May 2005 parliamentary elections by gunning down scores of demonstrators and putting prominent opposition politicians on trial for genocide and treason. But in smaller towns and villages throughout Ethiopia, his systemic repression escapes meaningful scrutiny. In the vast Oromia region, thousands of alleged government critics have been harassed, imprisoned, tortured and killed in the past decade. Millions have been intimidated into silence."
Statement by the International Republican Institute (IRI), IFES and the National Democratic Institute (NDI) on their expulsion by the Ethiopian government
My Dearest Socrates, Dema, Cheffe, Anbesaw, Alula Yemesker,Tazabe, Zena, Zombie and Wozeiro SC Condjo (The group of Stupid Cronies of Lebaking)
Let me say with these guys that “Let the WORLD knows more, the right pictures of your great LabaKing woyane".
If have no further comments, let these abovementioned cronies of LebaKing give more space in this column how they give endless explaination to our countrymen.
Stop your futile excercise. with a big threat of Taliban like govt. in Somalia, there is no way America will quarel with Ethiopia.
Anyways, you can keep on wasting your money!!! Long barking. One yr has passed, you are barking, we are building roads!!
Diaspora, don’t worry!Truth is on your side!
You do not need to hire lobbyists to to get what you want!
Meles the Tota is a monster,a dictator, we hate him!
These socalled lobbyists are a bunch of greedy unethical people withe either no principles or morals!
Let him throw his stolen money all over the place! He will never silence us or buy our surrender!
The only way for him is out!
Why can’t Meles just step down and the people vote on another leader. The only countries letting people stay in power over 15 years is dictatorships and Third -World Nations. Our governmental policies are all jacked up. Someone remind Meles that the democratic process includes leaders stepping aside so that the country can move on. Even Mandela had that much sense.
Meles & Co. may buy time by this stunt. His eventual demise is inevitable.
listen when are you guys stop looking answers for your problem from washington .it is so embarrasing .please your friends in dc dont have any respect to you .they just look at you as cry babies who dont have any idea why they are cring for.please have a respect for your self.if you love your country go and fight there .the reason epdrf is so successful is because it fights in its own country with its own people.
Thanks For the Woyanes:
During the time of the emperor or even during the more “progressive” Mengistu’s regime, it was unthinkable to talk an open parliamentary debate and discussion. Free press was out of question and the right to oppose way way way out of line. It may be times have changed a lot, or we are catching up with the global momentum, or somebody in the mountains and deserts of the Ethiopian topography shed blood for such a moment(God Bless Your Souls).
However, it is undeniable, that there are regimes close to our borders or in the Asian continent or in the American hemisphere, all the above mentioned rights and privileges are scarce. So are we expecting the heavens in this earth overnight (for CUD may be in about a year) or we just do not want to be thankful. All that is due to the son’s and daughters of the freedom fighters who led the aspiration of the broader masses right to the center of our Capital.
For most, in the Capitals of the Western countries, there is one thing you need to accept. It is very different to commit yourself to the freedom, equity, and prosperity of the Ethiopian public at large than to utter empty bluffs, gibberish ideas to just satisfy your own ego (because you lost the black now you are on the gray with no end in sight for your looser life-). Go to the real for front bring your ideas, alternatives and plans to the table, thanks for the Woyanes you can do that absolutely freely (Caution-All under the limit of our Constitution)
Please find other educated language.
Don’t be low class your self.
thank you zomby .tell this useless utopians that democracy is not as easy as getting drunk and write whatever nonsence you can imagine or laughing all the way to the bank in a good parking day.
You said:” Anyways, you can keep on wasting your money!!! Long barking. One yr has passed, you are barking, we are building roads!!”
My answer to you Blind Socrates; And where you took money to build this roads? dont ever say this is from government moneys, these moneys are came from huge loan given those vultures financer. These huge amount of money are calculated with “INTEREST” which is being paid by every Ethiopians including YOU!!! blind asshole!!!, including your sons and daughters and families, did you know that? even the new born babies they will pay these INTEREST.
I now you are boastfully saying we built roads? Yes! You guys built that roads, and I agreed that these projects are overpriced and a lot of Alibabas cutting troat kickbacks from the money of every Ethiopians by your members and cronies!!!
Your LEBAKING is really desperate to show his people and other countries that his leba & tyrant regime are building a lot of projects but a lot of alibabas and kickbacks (WITHOUT TRANSPARENCY) and while the every ETHIOPIANS are going down to RAVINE or WELL of DEATH!!!
Blind Socrates; Dont say that any people want Change & Reform are diaspora. Diaspora means dispersion of a people from their original homeland. And because of people same like YOU “blind asshole", the original Ethiopians are pushed out and became DIASPORA.
For me its better to call diaspora rather that NAZI and TYRANT blind ASSHOLE!!!
The unholy marriage:
I want to say from the start, what’s up with the honeymoon for AFD. It is has been historically seen parties of similar objective at least with some compromise could come to organize themselves for good intentions or for the worst. But CUD & OLF (there is something wrong with this picture)
Well, the point is if the OLF’s clear objective is as it was stated during the transitional period of the 1991, why going all the way to the arms while it could settle its agenda from the constitutional rights of the people for self determination with the consent of all the proud peoples of Oromia. Coming to the “ANDENET” “ETHIOPIAWINET” fanatics the CUD, if it is their true aspiration to respect people’s right for Self determination, why wouldn’t you even join with the EPRDF (I am confused here, that was what we have been telling you). Willingly or out of the necessity, CUD has acknowledge for such rights (thanks for the EPRDF, important lesson) and joined to the unholy marriage (Good Luck).
Now to the lighter side of my story this marriage looks the marriage between the Desperate Housewives (CUDs) and the Brokeman Mountain (OLF), My message for CUD- Like Sands of the Hour Glass, So are the Days of Our Lives. Watch your Back, it is back riding.
Stop loosing your cools?
Those on the EPRDF side seem to know how to use decent words and still make their points. I’m not surprised that they in power. My advice for any opposition supporter is to show some intelligence and coherence in his/her arguments, specially, in the counter points. A merry personal attack and name calling makes you look like hopeless and weak. Heed my advice and stop revealing too much.
I hear you gudu gana!
Thinking out of the BOOTH:
There was an article by a famous neuron physiologist in (SCIENCE, Vol 67, 19..) which he indicated that your either learning ability or rational thinking directly correlates with the amount of oxygen you get from natural ventilation. This was just a detour for where I am going with this (I am about to suggest the booth does not give you enough oxygen so breath fresh and think outside of the freakin booth-just for CUDs consumption).
There is too much out cry there in DC, where most of the “Patriotic” Diaspora is represented well in force, that is good and dandy. I do not have any problem with your know it all attitude and your look like the political gurus of every country and every nation. What bothers me is you are from Ethiopia ( I just said Ethiopia got it !) where poverty level is at its peak and rampant, and your fellow brother or sister is under distress for the daily bread. OK do not be agitated I am just telling you the truth (and it hurts, I know I know), if anything the Western countries are doing or helping you want to stop that (that is a shame and very vicious) you are ridiculous.
There is no doubt that Ethiopia is making a turn around and a significant progress (there is no turning back, history is being made as we speak). Either contribute positively in any meaningful way or just shut up and toil your a** of wherever you are (I know where you are).
Sorry I forget the BOOTH thing. I just want to ask you to think of your country, your neighbor back home, your schools, your Kebeles, that is thinking outside of the BOOOOOOTH or as we call it the BOX. Think globally and act locally. Support a child, support an elder or a patient, then you are a citizen of the world and very importantly ETHIOPIAN. That is way out of the BOOTH!
But With your Green Yellow RED bla bla bla flag roaming around the Departments of State and so on does not cut it at all, actually you look miserable.
For FANATIC CUDs: You really look a loser to me. I do not even like the way you talk and walk. You try to worship your so called leaders be smart fellas. And be careful that ride you took with the OLF that is horseback riding that is not RED LINE METRO riding OK.
I will see you next week from the Lovely Virginia Beach, enjoy people
“MY APOLOGIZE". . . . I will try and appreciated.
You said,“…Ethiopia ( I just said Ethiopia got it !) where poverty level is at its peak and rampant…”
And you also said, “There is no doubt that Ethiopia is making a turn around and a significant progress (there is no turning back, history is being made as we speak).”
I am scratching my head. Aren’t you contradicting yourself? I will leave the question and the answer for you. You truly are the living dead!
«_ethiopian airlines_» adoption agriculture airline airlines athletics aviation business caf china «commodity exchange» crime diaspora drought dv economy ecx energy eritrea «ethiopian airlines» famine fashion football health hydroelectric ict immigration investment islam manufacturing media «meles zenawi» migration mobile muslim nile olympics politics power press rail railway religion soccer sport style telecom train visa wikileaks