nazret.com
 

« The Role of Development Aid in fueling Corruption and Undermining Governance in EthiopiaEthiopia's FM Held Talks With Samsung's President and CEO in Seoul »

An Ethiopian walking on eggshells

advertisement

06/26/13

  11:05:23 pm, by admin, 2464 words  
Categories: Yilma Bekele

An Ethiopian walking on eggshells

An Ethiopian walking on eggshells

By Yilma Bekele

No question I have to be careful writing this column. That is why I choose the title. Some of us are quick to take offense or assume holier than thou attitude when it comes to the subject I am gingerly trying to confront. I decided to approach the issue head on and let the chips fall where they may.

It all started after reading my friend Dr. Fikre Tolosa’s article regarding the Oromo question in our homeland. I was impressed and empowered by his lucid analysis. His grasp of our ancient history is second to none and his piece on the current situation was a showcase of his vast knowledge. The response to his presentation did not fit the gravity of the subject matter he so carefully laid out. To say I was disappointed is an understatement. I expected a mature and open discussion so we can have clarity and help us see the problem that has confounded our people for quite a long time. There is nothing like looking at an old problem with a fresher perspective equipped with new knowledge and
experience gained from learning and observing.

Thus with my disappointment for those that claim to speak for the oppressed and down trodden I left the subject matter behind and moved on to other things. But that nagging feeling of searching for an opportunity to put the matter into some perspective stayed with me.

I was making my breakfast one early morning when I heard Public Radio discussing the anniversary of the assassination of Medgar Evers and the Mississippi of 1963. I was mesmerized by the story. For those that are not familiar with the history of America and its race relations I will do my best to give you a snapshot of the period.
The 1960 USA was a different country from what we see today. The two races white and black might as well have been living on different planets. They claim the north was a little different whatever that means but in the south USA being black was not a small matter. The State of Mississippi was ground zero for racism in its ugliest form. It was not de facto apartheid but it was definitely de facto segregation. The two races kept separate neighborhoods, separate schools and separate existence.

Medgar Evans, a veteran of World War II who fought for his country, a college graduate and a civil right campaigner applied to the University of Mississippi law school and his application was rejected due to his race. This was 1954. Mr. Evans continued his work in the civil rights movement by helping organize boycotts and setting up chapters of NAACP (National Alliance for the Advancement of Colored People) in his home state.

Some white folks in Mississippi did not appreciate the likes of Medgar Evans that were trying to upset the norm. Separate and unequal was their philosophy. Thus on June 12, 1963 a white fellow that took the distorted view to heart shot and killed Medgar Evans thinking that his act will stop the march of history. Here is the lyric to a beautiful song by Bob Dylan trying to make sense of this tragedy.

A bullet from the back of a bush took Medgar Evers’ blood
A finger fired the trigger to his name
A handle hid out in the dark
A hand set the spark
Two eyes took the aim
Behind a man’s brain
But he can’t be blamed
He’s only a pawn in their game.

How true, the hapless individual with no name was just a ‘pawn in their game’. I felt a strong sense of attachment and empathy to Medgar Evans. He was not a complainer. He was an activist. Despite the danger to himself and his family Medgar worked to right what he felt was wrong. That was the story being told on the radio the morning as I was making my breakfast.

You see they were not discussing how awful it was to be a black person in Mississippi in 1963 but rather how things have changed due to heroes like Medgar. There was lynching, separate bathrooms, designated water fountains, unequal schools and a whole bunch of grievances to talk about but what was the point of dwelling on the negatives when one can construct on the positive? Slavery was an ugly period with the consequences still lingering until today. There is no denying that when you look at the America of 2013. But in that radio program they choose to take a positive approach. Remember the past but look what has been achieved in such a short time and build on that was the message.
And I thought here are a people brought with chains to serve, systematically dehumanized due to the color of their skin, psychologically whipped and untold atrocity visited on them but are triumphatically celebrating their endurance with hope and I was humbled. I was filled with a new sense of my ability to overcome and thrive. The sacrifice of Medgar Evans in Mississippi gave perspective to the suffering of my people in Ethiopia and the possibility of one day celebrating such a bright future in my ancient land. I thought of Professor Asrat that suffered for my freedom, I remembered Assefa Maru that was gunned in broad daylight for his resolve not to bow down, I stay up nights thinking of my brother Eskinder and Andulalem, Bekele, Wubeshet, my sister Reyot and many others enduring pain on my behalf. I dare not complain because it is a lot better to work harder so their sacrifice is not in vain.

My education did not end there. A few days later the same Public Radio brought out the story of race relations in the state of Alabama. This was another dramatic story with a positive twist. It took place in June of 1963 and the setting was another place of higher education. The person being interviewed is the daughter of the then Governor of the state and she was only a 13 years old girl at the time when the tragic drama took place. On that fateful day her father stood in front of the University of Alabama to block a black person from registering. The confrontation between the state and the federal government was a made for a picture moment. George Wallace the Governor lost but he made his point when he vainly declared ‘segregation now, segregation tomorrow and segregation forever.’

Peggy Wallace the daughter is one of those rare human beings that are able to emerge from such a tumultuous period with integrity. Her father redefined himself in the later part of his life but what struck me most was her statement ‘I am a Wallace but I am different.’ In the radio interview she said ‘It has taken me a lifetime to step out from the shadow of the schoolhouse door….I decided I wanted to leave a legacy for my children ... one of change. If you have the courage to find your own voice, you can make change. I wanted Burns and Leigh (her children) to know that their mother found her voice and had the courage to stand for change. That she wanted change. That she did change.’
The two stories lifted the feeling of hopelessness and the heavy burden I feel when I think of my homeland. It is good to know that individual action could galvanize a whole nation to stop and pay attention. Medgar Evans sacrifices on behalf what is right and George Wallace’s defiance against what is just made people realize change is necessary. The nation was confronted with the reality that evil things were happening and no one is free when others are oppressed.

My happy thoughts were jarred when I listened to a Voice of America interview with an individual presenting himself as an Ethiopian historian. Ato Gebrekidan Desta is other things but definitely not a historian. Listening to his bombastic analysis it is easy to tell that his whole purpose was to settle a score not to enlighten or find a meaning in a scholarly manner. It looks like he first arrived at a certain conclusion and went about looking for incidents to fit his theory. He reminded me of our Woyane leaders that never miss a chance to condemn the Derg while at the same time working hard to emulate and surpass the atrocity they so much hated and supposedly fought to get rid of.
Our friend Ato Gebrekidan passionately puts down early Ethiopian history and the leaders in his vain attempt to build the resume of Atse Yohanes. He dismisses all historians as tools of other Ethiopian kings while blindly forging ahead to construct his own reality regarding his favorite king Atse Yohanes. I was appalled when Ato Gebrekidan dismissed all previous historians as nothing but tools of the old regime. Such worthy intellectuals as Belaten Geta Hiruy Welde Selassie, Dr. Sergew Hable Selassie, Bahru Zewde, Richard Pankhurst, Donald Levine, Harold Marcus and other giants were all considered unworthy of respect.

I have not read or come across a historian worthy of his profession that has disparaged or dismissed the contributions of Atse Yohanes and the part he has contributed to enrich our ancient history. On the other hand there is no need to belittle and vilify others so as to put him high on a pedestal. Ato Gebrekidan speaks more like a hired cadre with a mission not like a professional, a teacher and seeker of the truth.

I am grateful to VOA for inviting Dr. Shumet Sishagne to give us a better perspective on how to look at history and how to talk in a civilized manner with the goal being to teach but not preach. Dr. Shumet, God bless him is a perfect example of what it means to be an expert on a subject. In a calm and reserved manner he was able to give us perspective on how we view our past and how we interpret the event that took place to establish what we call home today.

Whether we like or not, whether we approve or not there is a country called Ethiopia and there are over eighty million souls that are physically and politically recognized by the international community to be residents of that defined space. While countries still are waging wars to conquer and increase their physical size we in Ethiopia have actively been engaging in dismantling the big to create mini kingdoms. The first causality is Eritrea and thanks to the largesse of the TPLF party today for the first time in our history our country does not have access to the sea. Although the TPLF party’s main agenda was to create another enclave for obvious and other reasons it did not materialize. Unfortunately there are still a few that keep insisting on resetting the clock back to the last century to the time when we each tribe or ethnic group was isolated from their neighbors and ruled by a despot, a warlord or hereditary king.

That was the response to Dr. Fikre’s article which I mentioned at the beginning of this piece. Some were vividly remembering what happened during the period of nation building and presenting it as a crime. Fortified with imagination fueled with hate it looks like they want to settle a dispute which took place may be over a hundred years ago right now and today. Their emotional outburst confounds most that have a difficult time relating to a part of history that is old, outdated or not in the radar of the average person that has moved on to other things in life. It is sad to see some that supposedly have tasted enlightenment with college degrees to prove it and tasked with the burden of higher expectations by their people sink low and peddle ethnic politics for fleeting ego massage.
No one can turn back the march of time. The responsibility with the generations to come is learn from history so what was done wrong would be righted and educate themselves and their children to avoid future mishaps. The example I gave regarding Mississippi and Alabama are perfect examples where the responsible action of using the law and open discussion have resulted bringing about a just and fair system. The job is not done yet but looking at the foundation laid it is easy to predict that whatever comes next would be positive and a plus.

If such approach can overcome the hurt and hate that engulfed the black American population that was bought and sold as a commodity, held separate and systematically kept ignorant surely in our country where the different ethnic groups have intermarried, worship together and have so much in common the chances of building an all-inclusive society is not a fools dream. There is no need to go around looking for proof when all we got to do is look deep at our own linage and see the rainbow nature of our family tree.

It is easy to hate. It is a lazy persons approach to explain difficult situations with hysteria and moronic one lines. Giving a smart and reserved response requires knowledge and common sense. Some choose to cater to the lowest denominator among us and hurl insults or question a person’s character and integrity when confronted with the truth.
Dr. Fikre’s questions have not been answered yet. Those that advocate separation and going it their way have not made their case why such action will result in a better situation for the people they are trying to liberate. They have not explained the many important but grave issues of dealing with millions of people that will be caught in the middle. This article is not enough neither would it try to point out the many consequences of such drastic measures advocated by some but any discussion should address all issues that come with acts of national divorce. On the other hand the proven and successful means employed by the US, South Africa among others should be looked at closely to solve a national problem that needs to be dealt with delicately.

I also believe while not belittling the national question to me at this moment in time the number one question confronting our country is the issue of Democracy and respect for Human Right. Solving those two important questions would naturally resolve the issue of equality. Respect for individual right will translate to respect for right of nationalities. I believe our time and effort is better spent on getting rid of the Woyane group that is the cause of all problems and the source of disharmony among the children of Ethiopia. I urge you to please read the articles and video this piece is based on.

18 comments

Comment from: Visitor [Visitor]
Visitor

Thank you so much for righting this article. Every time I hear one-sided views and read hateful comments online about Ethiopia and our ethnic groups, I often feel so disappointed. You basically voice my believe and it is so great to know that there is someone else that thinks this way. For me, I can’t even express my true views within my own family because they have strong one-sided views and it is automatically assumed by them and others that I would feel the same way and believe the same things. I just wish people actually think about the consequences (possible ending) before they settle on a stubborn belief. Separation is an option but it is not the best option. Thank You!!!

06/27/13 @ 00:24
Comment from: lion [Visitor]
lion

‘Woyane group that is the cause of all problems and the source of disharmony among the children of Ethiopia. I urge you to please read the articles and video this piece is based on.’
It is this type of mentality that is the cause of a lot of our problems. How can we even deal with TPLF when we step on Tigrayan history. Part of getting together is at least recognizing eachother’s histories whether we like it or not. People only push others away when they put eachothers heritage down. There were two woyane revolutions and they are looked at positively by Tigrayans just like Miniliks history is looked at positively by others. For example Mr Yilma kinda tries to excuse some wrongs by putting them in the context of nation building. Instead of calling some oppressors, some traitors and some separatists why dont we start by at least somewhat recognizing that each group or even person thinks they’re right and they’re the ones doing good. Instead of adhari lets say opposition instead of the hateful myriad of things EPRDF, TPLF and tigrayans are called lets name them by what they at least call themselves. Thats the ABC of politics or even tolerance.
I dont even know why I’m wasting my time. I’ll probably be called a lot of things and I’ve noticed cadres from both sides are the first to comment. lol. So I dont know what is going to be said. God bless Ethiopia, The Oromo people, The Tigrayans, Amharas, Somalis and the myriad of people’s we have in Ethiopia. I dont wish evil for my country. let’s build on Ethiopia by accepting what there is and by insisting for what is missing. Why are we so keen to wish for destruction. God bless you all.
P.S- Nazret I’m happy you’re become more and more mature. At least you seem to care about your reputation. The fact you are being called a woyane (imagine) is telling. Lol.

06/27/13 @ 00:41
Comment from: Proud Oromo [Visitor]
Proud Oromo

Leave the Oromo question for the Oromos to decide. You never walked in their shoes to understand their values and desires as an individual and as a group of people. If you believe in freedom and democracy, the last thing you should do is not to impose your wills and desires on others; not to dictate others to accept your terms. Learn to accept and respect differences.

06/27/13 @ 00:59
Comment from: Tera Wotader [Visitor]
Tera Wotader

I noted that you got a lot in your mind, and you like to share what you got. But your writings are full of cluster. For instance, you don’t need to tell your readers you have to be careful about what you are going to write, just write it carefully.

In short, consider to write precisely and effectively.

Due to the above comments, hope you do not think that I am TPLF.

06/27/13 @ 02:43
Comment from: Unity [Visitor]
Unity

Dear Yilma

I am glad Ethiopia has children like you. The politics of hatred, racisim and tribalisim will not stand the power of reasoning. Thank you for shading light in to the darkness. Some loosers want to employ the Woyane and Shabia tactic to help them take power.

06/27/13 @ 04:00
Comment from: mesfin_b [Member]  
mesfin_b

አቶ ይልማ በቀለ እንደተለመደው ጥሩ ትንታኔ ያዘለ ጽሁፍ ነው ያቀረብክልን::
ምስጋናዬ ከፍ ያለ ነው::
አንዳንድ ምሁራን አንድ አቅጣጫ ብቻ ይዘው ነገሮችን ለማየት ሲሞክሩ በሌላ በኩል ያለው ሁኔታ ችግር ይፈጥራል::
ስለዚህ አመለካከት ከሁሉም አቅጣጫ መሆን ግዴታ ነው::
አለበዚያ ጠባብነትን ያንጸባርቃል::
:):):)
ጠባብነት ደግሞ ወደ የግለሰብን አስተያየት ብቻ ተመርኩዞ እኔ ብቻ አዋቂ ብሎም ፈላጭ ቆራጭ ነኝ ማለትን ያጠነክራል::
ይህ የት እንደሚያደርስ ማወቅ አያዳግትም::

06/27/13 @ 06:39
Comment from: Zabarga Alemu [Visitor]
Zabarga Alemu

The whole idea such writing is about constant day dreaming and missing the over 120 years of amara tyrany that pampered and enriched amaras(sorry Ethiopians) while impoverishing and dehumanizing all the non amara nations and nationalities in that country. And now some 20 years of missing such master privilages inorder to become just one among others produces endless moanings after moanings whether you call it walking on eggshells or better even walking on marshy land.

Please just learn to treat others and yourself as equals rather than preaching your well known hidden supermacist amara ideology to be imposed on others ever since the amara ruling class elites planted strong seeds of distruction that still working as time time to explod at any time.

06/27/13 @ 18:19
Comment from: etie [Visitor]
etie

Ethiopia iSnot america there many nations with clear boundaries and different histories which must be recognise.there is not ethiopian language but amara language oromo la.guage ……..sidama langauge……

Many official la guages ethnic states this is the east african states which will replaces fake ethiopia amhara and amharigna speaking

06/27/13 @ 22:31
Comment from: Unity [Visitor]
Unity

Dear “Proud Oromo”

The real Oromo Question or desire revolves around unity, peace, love, democracy, development, and justice just like the rest of the Ethiopian people. The writer is promoting that and you are against it, yet you call yourself Proud Oromo. This is an article every human being, black or white, Oromo or otherwise needs to be proud of. Do not be proud or ashamed of being oromo, Amhara, Black, White, China, Ethiopia, short, tall, man, woman, etc…because none of us chose to take that identity. Your pride needs to come from what you did and chose conciously. Grow up ok!

06/28/13 @ 04:56
Comment from: Mestewat [Visitor]
Mestewat

omment from: Unity [Visitor]
“Dear Yilma

I am glad Ethiopia has children like you. The politics of hatred, racisim and tribalisim will not stand the power of reasoning. Thank you for shading light in to the darkness.” you wrote

What do you call the amara political system that killed Oromo language and replaced it with amara language, killed oromo religion and replaced with amara religion(orthodox) confisicated Oromo territories, fertle lands and named it amara territory (Code named Ethiopian)

Imposed amara language as the country’s ONLY academic language completely and 100% favouring ONLY amara children like you and the liar article author against the completely disfranchised Oromo and other non amara children out competed and left to suffer in poverty and darkness far too long.

This and many similar inhumanities of the amara system are in FACT the politics of Hatred, Racisim and naked Tribalisim that can not stand the power of reasoning at all. We must thank all humanists and human rights advocates for shading light in to the darkness and expose stupid liars blaming the vicims.

06/28/13 @ 10:22
Comment from: Peter [Visitor]
Peter

Long live Ethiopia. The victory of Adwa has supported the African Americans cause for freedom and equality of races.

06/28/13 @ 21:31
Comment from: Baba [Visitor]
Baba

Thew writer is totally confused deep down to his bone marrows by already claiming that he is walking on eggshells while in fact HE IS WALKING ON TIME BOMB planted by his ancestors in the form of unjust amara dictatorial system still going strong by other means.

So he better stop halucinating and come to his right mind and try to defuse the old time bombs instead of covering it up and letting them simmer underground like the volcano. That is what love and peace means. Reality talks! :)

06/29/13 @ 10:10
Comment from: obsaa [Visitor]
obsaa

Dear Dr Yilma:
Your article has many fallacies and invalid arguments. Just to cite some examples:

1. Why you missed to write the unruly behavior of Dr Fikre. This man all of a sudden proposed that the oromo people should stop use of Latin script. He proposed to establish a fake center of studies for Oromo history. If he were really interested on Oromo studies he could have started earlier. Why not he join the already existing oromo study organizations such as OSA. Rather he is a banda/enemy who is pretending to be an Oromo. He is a wolf in sheep covering.

2. Ato Gebrekidan has given his evidences in a civilized manner on VOA. Unless you are derived by hatred for Tigres you have no reason to make his analysis less worthy than that of Dr Shumet. Can you provide more evidence and logic to falsify him?

06/29/13 @ 14:56
Comment from: Obsitu [Visitor]
Obsitu

Amaras and Oromos are not enemies as few Wolega elites in the diaspora want us to believe. I like to read articles like this. Yilma Bekle, you are not walking on eggs for stating the truth. If there is any scholar that does not agree with you, let him come out and say how you are wrong. Thank you to the writer. I know the historically respected place of Oromos in Ethiopia and their peacful coexistence with Amaras is head ache to handful of racist individuals.

06/29/13 @ 23:31
Comment from: Mango [Visitor]
Mango

Dr Fekre Tolosa must teach us more. The mouth speaks from the abundance of the heart. Only those stupids that want to humiliate and downgrade the Oromo people are blindly opposing it without giving reasons.

06/30/13 @ 03:13
Comment from: Thee x [Visitor]
Thee x

The so called Ethiopian history , is not Ethiopian history it is Amharas history . And even today the educated Amharas never learn the mistake of ther ancestors or try to strait it up ,if they got a chance they are going to finish it what started 120 years ago by minlik .have any one read or learn the history of Oromo , Somali , sidama , welayita. Or benealushangul. ? Or all other Ethiopian tribes are not Ethiopians ?

06/30/13 @ 23:43
Comment from: Yirgacheffee [Visitor]
Yirgacheffee

Those eggs were laid by some ex-Derg dreaming about power.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

07/01/13 @ 10:42
Comment from: hiwot [Visitor]
hiwot

እንዳው እናንተ ሰዎች ኦሮሞን እና አማራን ከማፋቀር ይልቅ ማፋጀት ይበጃል ብላችሁ ነዉ የምትደክሙት? የፈለጋችሁትን ፊደል ተጠቀሙ የፈለጋችሁትንም ቕንቕኣ ተጠቀሙ እኔም እንደዛው :: ትግሬ ብሆንም አማርኛ መናገር ከብዙ ሰው ጋር ሲለሚያግባባኝ እና ኢትዮጵያ ዉስጥ ለመነገድ ስለሚጠቅመኝ አማርኛ አምሮኝ አይምሮዬ ተስማምቶታል:: ኦሮምኛም እሞክራለሁ:: ዉጭ ሃገር ከሄድኩ ደግሞ የፈረንጂ አፍ ያዋጣኛል::ሞኝ አትሁኑ እሺ.

07/02/13 @ 05:40

rebtel

advertisements

The views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of nazret.com. The views are solely that of the author. Become a blogger of nazret.com, the #1 Rated Ethiopian Website according to Alexa. Contact us for details

Search

  XML Feeds

multiblog engine
© nazret.com The Most Popular Ethiopian Website. nazret is Ranked #1 by Alexa and Qantcast.
All Rights Reserved 1994-2014
About Us | Contact | Feedback | Help | Privacy | Terms and Conditions