nazret.com
 

« Ethiopia: A Closer Look into Jawar Mohammed's AssessmentAccess Capital adds its own to the on-going debate on Ethiopia’s economic performance »

Ethiopia: Middle Passage to the Middle East

advertisement

01/16/12

  10:20:48 am, by admin, 2728 words  
Categories: Ethiopia

Ethiopia: Middle Passage to the Middle East

Ethiopia: Middle Passage to the Middle East

From the International Slave Trade to the International Maid Trade

By Alemayehu G. Mariam

In the days of the Atlantic slave trade, the Middle Passage was the journey of slave trading ships from the west coast of Africa to the New World. Portuguese, British, French, Spanish, Dutch and other slave traders maintained outposts along the African coast to transact their business with their local slave raiding partners. Millions of African slaves were sold or traded for manufactured goods or raw materials. In the grueling journey, the slaves were often shackled and chained to the floor to gain maximum cargo capacity. Many died from disease, starvation, dehydration and suffocation. Many also committed suicide by jumping overboard. Those who resisted their masters were beaten and even killed. Plantation owners treated the slaves like cattle; and those working in the fields were often flogged and beaten. Female slaves were the objects of sexual desire and abuse by their masters.  The law required runaway slaves (“fugitive slaves”) who escaped their bondage to be returned to their masters who punished them severely.

There is a Middle Passage of sorts taking place today from Ethiopia to the Middle East. It is what lawyerKhaled Ali Beydoun and others have described as the Ethiopian “Maid Trade”.Today a network of unscrupulous modern-day slave-traffickers (“human traffickers”) and “private labor employment agencies” operating under license by the ruling regime in Ethiopia transship thousands of young Ethiopian women to various parts of the Middle East to work as domestic servants in what amounts to “contract slavery” with little follow up and monitoring to ensure their well-being and welfare in their host countries.

The plight of Ethiopian women domestic workers in the Middle East has beendocumented in Bina Fernandez’s survey research (Ch. 7).  In 2009, “over 74,000 people risked their lives to enter Yemen en route to Saudi Arabia, of which 42,000 were Ethiopians.”  According to official data, 91% of the Ethiopian domestic workers in the Middle East were single women, 83% between the age of 20–30 age group, 63% had some secondary education, 26% were illiterate and 71% Muslim and 93% earned US$100–150 per month. Some of these women “officially registered with the government as a migrant worker”.  Others “worked through illegal brokers who are viciously exploitative [and] often take the women’s money and sometimes abandon them in the desert before they even reach Somalia.”

The “Middle Passage” of Middle East “contract slavery” for the young Ethiopian women is unspeakably harrowing.  Their working conditions are described as slave-like, except, as Beydoun argues, “Shackles and whips have been replaced by more inventive designs to dehumanize, suppress, and subsequently enslave persons for economic or sexual purposes.”  Fernandez reported that the women live-in domestic workers she interviewed were “on-call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and working between 10 and 20 hours daily.” Some of the women pulled “double duty– that is, cleaning or doing laundry for a second household, usually a relative of their employer.” Most of these women got “only one day off a month, or no break at all.” Many of these women experienced “complete physical exhaustion” and often suffered “mental breakdown” unable to “tell what day of the week it was, or what time it was.” They faced extreme physical, mental and sexual abuse. In August 2011, the world witnessed the shocking video of Shweyga Mullah, a young Ethiopian woman who cared for two of Moammar Gadhafi’s grandchildren in Libya. Because Shweyga refused to beat one of the grandchildren, Gadhaffi’s daughter-in-law “tied her hand behind her back, taped her mouth and poured boiling water on her scalding her entire body.” She suffered first degree burns over her entire body. Extreme physical and sexual abuse of Ethiopiandomestic workers is not uncommon elsewhere in the Middle East as documented by Al Jazeera in 2009 in the United Arab Emirates.

Fernadez further found that that “verbal abuse by employers is commonplace” including “racial insults and discriminatory behaviour (such as separate food and dishes for them) as is non-payment or underpayment of wages. To escape their conditions, some are forced to become “runaways”. They end up doing “live-out domestic workers, brewing and selling illicit liquor, or engaging in sex work.” But they are trapped. Fernandez explains, “Their lack of legal status makes them vulnerable to greater exploitation if they are detected, as they risk blackmail, imprisonment, and/or deportation. If they wish to leave voluntarily, they often have to pay highfines for exit visas.”

On the other hand, Beydoun argues that the young Ethiopian women trafficked in the “maid trade” in Lebanon are often clueless about “what their commitment entails, and the imminent risks and hazards they will likely endure during migration and employment.” They face enormous dangers including  “overcharging of fees; debt bondage; falsification of documents; deception with regard to the nature and conditions of employment, contract substitution, exploitation and abuse, lack of preparation for employment abroad, including lack of predeparture training; forced/coerced recruitment, including being kidnapped or sold to illegal recruiters or traffickers; hazardous journey to the country of destination.”

Tears of the Ethiopian Maids

In a recent Youtube video, an unnamed young Ethiopian woman confronts a representative of the regime of Meles Zenawi in a meeting hall in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The words of this young woman in the 2 minute video are so powerful, so overwhelming and so penetrating that the listener is brought to convulsive tears. She complains about the mistreatment and dehumanization she and other maids continue to face in life and in death in the UAE, and laments the depraved indifference of her “government” to speak up, defend and protect them from gross abuses of human rights.

…. If we run away from [our abusive employers], there is a chance we can die. There is a woman who tells us to run away. But they don’t help us. If [we] run away, we need money to pay for rent and food. [We] don’t have to run away. As much as possible, it is better to help [us]. When we live in this country [UAE], sometimes we die. Many of us are buried here. Why must an Ethiopian be buried in the Emirates? Why is that our government does not check on us, follow up on our conditions, ask about us? Why should I be buried in a foreign country? It does not matter if we are Christian or Muslim. This question has deprived me sleep. When I bow to pray, I have not been able to do so properly. Only God knows. All I do is cry. Even our dead bodies must not be buried in this country. [There was a domestic worker accused of killing her employer.] It is possible she may have done something wrong. Her government should stand and defend her and advocate for her. She should be punished as appropriate [if she is guilty] by her family or the law… We learned [within a few days of her arrest] that she was killed by the authorities [in the Emirates].

As she concluded her statement, this young woman cries out in pain, her voice quivering, tears in her eyes and pleading for an answer from someone, anyone:

            Where is Ethiopia’s flag? I can’t take it anymore. I can’t take it anymore…!!!!

It was enough to make a grown man cry. It would be impossible to find a more patriotic, resolute, unwavering, steadfast and true-to-the-core Ethiopian than this young woman!! When those who have a chokehold on power declare with depraved indifference that “Ethiopia’s flag is a piece of rag”, this unnamed young Ethiopian woman cries her heart out looking of her lost Ethiopian flag. Bless her heart!

The Response of Zenawi’s Regime – Blame the Maids!

The response of Meles Zenawi’s regime to the plight of these women is morally calloused and depraved. Fernandez reported: “The term ‘runaway’ was used in a pejorative sense by one Ethiopian government official and several of the PEA [private employment agency] representatives during interviews, to describe these women as delinquents who abandon their contractual responsibilities because they do not want to work hard, and want an easy life.” Beydoun argues that the ruling regime’s efforts to combat trafficking in Lebanon were symbolic and ineffective despite the fact that an inter-agency anti-trafficking task force had been established to deal with the problem. He concluded, “Trafficked women are particularly vulnerable where their own governments fail to adequately protect them.”

Since 1998, Zenawi’s regime has put in place a “Private Employment Agency Proclamation No. 104/1998”, which provided for licensing of private employment agencies and the prosecution of illegal brokers. In 2009, this Proclamation was repealed and updated by the “Employment Exchange Services Proclamation No. 632/2009”, which required private employment agencies, among other things, “not to recruit a job seeker below the age of 18 years; not to terminate the contract of employment before acquiring the consent of the worker in writing, get approval from the Ethiopian embassy or consular office to form a new contract or to modify the existing one, register a worker sent abroad, within fifteen days, with the nearest Ethiopian embassy or consular office.”  The “private employment agency which sends workers abroad” is mandated to ensure that the working conditions in the host country not “be less favorable to an Ethiopian than the rights and benefits of those who work in a similar type and level of work in the country of employment.” The foreign employer is required to pay the “visa fee of the country of destination, round trip ticket, residence and work permit fees and insurance coverage” for the worker. Moreover, “any private employment agency which sends a worker abroad for work” must deposit cash or post bond in the minimum amount of  USD$30,000 for up to 500 workers “for the protection and enforcement of the rights of the worker.”

The real penalty for violation of the Proclamation No. 632 is suspension, revocation or cancellation of license of the employment agency. Though various stiff criminal penalties are provided in Article 40, there is little evidence of serious prosecution of human traffickers. According to a 2010 State Department report, “Between March and October 2009, the [Federal High Court’s 11th Criminal] bench heard 15 cases related to transnational labor trafficking, resulting in five convictions, nine acquittals, and one withdrawal due to missing witnesses. Of the five convictions, three offenders received suspended sentences of five years’ imprisonment, two co-defendants were fined, and one offender is serving a sentence of five years’ imprisonment.”

Similarly, according to a 2011 UNHCR report, “The [Ethiopian] government showed only nascent signs of engaging destination country governments in an effort to improve protections for Ethiopian workers and obtain protective services for victims.” Moreover, “although licensed employment agencies must place funds in escrow in the event a worker's contract is broken, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has never used these deposits to pay for victims' transportation back to Ethiopia.” But the regime has readily come to the rescue of other victims of human traffickers according to the same UNHCR report: “In 2010, Ethiopia granted asylum to 1,383 Eritrean refugees deported from Egypt, many of whom claim to have been brutalized by Rashaida smugglers operating in the Sinai – including conditions of forced construction labor – or have fled Eritrea to escape situations of forced labor associated with the implementation of the country's national service program.” While it is noble and morally commendable to assist any victim of human trafficking and human rights abuse, it is also true that charity begins at home.

What Can Be Done to Help Ethiopian Women Caught Up in the “Maid Trade”?

The international movement of labor is a fact of international life. For a poor country such as Ethiopia where unemployment is high, workers who migrate abroad are a source of much needed financial support for their families, and a source of remittances for the country in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually. But slavery, by any other name including contract slavery”, is still slavery. It is just as cruel, oppressive, exploitive, dehumanizing and degrading. These women are extremely vulnerable and have no rights and no means of support to vindicate their rights. Various commentators have argued that the demand for Ethiopian domestic workers will continue long-term as they are considered cheaper and more obedient. In other words, they are considered “model maids” who put up with a lot of abuse in quiet desperation.

One can point to international legal and moral obligations to help out these women and effectively combat human trafficking camouflaged as migrant labor. Among the relevant Conventions and protocols include: the United Nations Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, the United Nations Protocol against the Smuggling of Migrants by Land, Sea, and Air, the  Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women and the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime and its two related protocols. Discussion of legal and moral state obligations under these Conventions would be an exercise in futility. Talking law to those who sneer and thumb their noses at the rule of law is a waste of time. So is making a moral plea or appealing to conscience as both presuppose the existence of a moral plane of discussion. All that can be done is explain what can be done!

If the problem of “contract slavery” in the Ethiopian “maid trade” is going to be addressed effectively, serious criminal investigations and prosecutions must be pursued against violators.  The aggressive crackdown that has long been directed at the independent press in Ethiopia should be re-directed to the gangs of criminal human traffickers. Various scholars and researchers have offered effective recommendations to deal with the problem including the provision of domestic skills training in a Middle Eastern context to Ethiopian women in attempt to lessen their vulnerability, working with NGOs as partner organizations to monitor their working conditions and  working with host countries  to make it easy for these workers to use the banking institutions. Some have suggested ways of improving access to the criminal justice system of the host country by providing a confidential complaint reporting process for abuse and wage payment related issues and legal assistance, expanding victim services such as shelters and hotlines engaging civil society and faith-based groups to offer assistance. There are lessons to be learned from the experiences of other countries such as the Philippines which  maintains an Overseas Employment Administration Agency to secure the interests of Filipino workers throughout the world.

Slavery By Any Other Name 

Slavery was not abolished in Saudi Arabia and Yemen until 1962. A year later it was abolished in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). In the 1950s, Saudi Arabia had an estimated 450,000 slaves, nearly 20 percent of the population. Perhaps it should come as no surprise that “contract slavery” of domestic servants continues in these countries. The deep tracks of slavery do not vanish easily in the desert sand in a mere 50 years. The vast majority of the Ethiopian domestic workers end up in these three countries. In 2009, “over 74,000 people risked their lives to enter Yemen en route to Saudi Arabia, of which 42,000 were Ethiopians.” The “kafala” or sponsorship system in the Gulf States gives disproportionate power to the sponsor (employer) in the “contract” relationship. If the worker breaks her contract, she bears the cost of her return ticket and will likely pay fines and pay debts to the employment agency that arranged the sponsorship. There is no running away from “contract slavery” particularly since the migrant worker is required to surrender her passport (if legally in the country) to the employer. Through the maids may be able to run away from their cruel employers, they cannot hide. They are frequently arrested as fugitive workers, not unlike fugitive slaves of yesteryears. Unable to change their circumstances, these women endure in quiet desperation often for years.

Slavery by any other name is still slavery. In truth, there can be no “contract slavery” since only free men and free women can enter into any contracts, which leaves many of the Ethiopian women domestic workers as nothing but slaves and at best indentured servants. Article 4 of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights guarantees that “No one shall be held in slavery or servitude, slavery and the slave trade shall be prohibited in all their forms.” We must all do what we can to help our Ethiopian sisters to rise up from “contract slavery”!

“Where is Ethiopia’s flag?”

Previous commentaries by the author are available at: www.huffingtonpost.com/alemayehu-g-mariam/ and http://open.salon.com/blog/almariam/

16 comments

Comment from: Truth [Visitor]
Truth

It is Monday, the headache is getting worse, it is becoming migraine for woyanes and their lapdogs

01/17/12 @ 00:11
Comment from: gashe_mamo [Member]  
gashe_mamo

You have brought an issue which is very complex. It involves agencies, the host country with its legal issues, the maids and their original country. They are all interrelated and there is a problem in one or two; For example when they put a pressure on the agencies a new way was opened for the illegal traffickers. When it is tried to teach the maids the basic right, there economic conditions makes them sign a deal which is favorable to the employer.
In the long run, the best option is to fight poverty back home and create job opportunity; Our culture should also be shaped up, so as to respect any kind of job.
For all who are already there, it should have been the task of the consulate and embassy to stand up and fight for our sisters. We all know our rulers neglected its citizens inside the country or abroad, so in my opinion it is best to make the issue as public as possible so that the international community will be aware of the situation & make force all parties to respect laws and agreements.

01/17/12 @ 00:11
Comment from: WHATEVER [Visitor]
WHATEVER

This is sad and should angry all black people. I’m tired of Africa being associated with slavery and human trafficing. Black people is Gods original people, our plight in this modern day world is a damn shame!! One day, when we are done diviiding and fighting among ourselves, we will be returned back to our greatness, I just hope its before the world ends.

01/17/12 @ 00:17
Comment from: addiszemen [Member]  
addiszemen

Almaria PINOCHIO, your nose seems to grow bigger and bigger each day you post an article.
Wey afincho, now you start degrading our poor sisters who chose to work hard with whatever it takes mentallity to help their famillies calling them slaves. What do you care and what do you know about modern day Ethiopia, other than sniffing around to seek negative news about our country?
The govt has given a much needed travel freedom and has no control of each household’s kitchen. Most of all we cannot impose any influence in other sovereign nation domestic law. All we can do is to open our embassy door and listen to the grievances of our sisters, like you saw it above.
People’s mentallity back home is always about going to a foreign land. How ever you explain to them that the outside world is not as pearly as they expected, no one hears you. All they want is, just to go and see it in their own eyes. Then when everything turnes out unexpectedly hard, depresion kicks in and that’s where the problem starts. So, almaria pinochio, stop your nonesense lie and repent.
Btw, kudos, you mentioned the name eritrea in your article for the first time ever.

01/17/12 @ 00:18
Comment from: C'est moi senait [Visitor]
C'est moi senait

The modern women slave trademarked run b Azeb of Meles weyannes are now multy mllioners that is only Ethiopia women sex industry, not a child or organ industry include.
Tigrians women and men are in mas exodus these days. This is a silence mass exodus next to operation mose.

God know how many ar raped and killed in those failty Arab countries.
Can Addis zemen provide us with this statistic ? Hahaha…

01/17/12 @ 01:20
Comment from: TEDDY [Visitor]
TEDDY

Poor Lady !!What a SHAME while our
systers and bros are actually treated as SLAVES by Arab employers
Agazi Officials and Tigre Mafiosis including the evil Azeb are spending
million of dollars in shopping in Dubai .By the way Adgi Banda what the hell are you talking about ,of course your Leba master and his Agazis specially his evil wife along the Tigre Mafiosis are benefiting from the Smuggling of these ladies by Arab Slave traders .
Hope you’re not going to mebtion the
Saudi Tycoon ,the great BIENFAITOR
of your Leba Master ,how Gulf States
so called businesmen are so good for
Ethiopia .Better to remind you that your other Master Issayass with his own Mafiosis is also the other benefitor of the illegal “Human Trade “business with Gulf States Emirs.

01/17/12 @ 01:54
Comment from: TEDDY [Visitor]
TEDDY

Adgi Banda and Co. Aiga gangs infecting this website .Now you can see by yourselveses how your leba master is financing your evil mission in USA .You gain a “Blood Money” earns with the Suffering of this poor Lady and many of our systers in Middle East Countries .While your leba master with his evil wife is dealing with their torturers !!!
KEEP ON BARKING LEKAMI KILETAM BANDAS !!!!!

01/17/12 @ 02:07
Comment from: TEDDY [Visitor]
TEDDY

Ethiopian Flag ,has ceased to exist
since May 1991 !!! Insulted by the
crime Minister !!!Strown down and burnt by the bandit Agazis for the sake of their Shabyan Master !!!While their thuggy supporters and their parasite cadres are on this website are supposing giving us a lesson of “PATRIOTISM” .Who said “Bandira Malet Betchaki TCherk
nehu” Crime Minister Melas Zerafew ,
who waved Shabyan Symbol than Ethiopian National flag “TPLF Star Iyassu Berehe ” !!!!

01/17/12 @ 02:18
Comment from: Shameful [Visitor]
Shameful

AidsZemen,
The girl is asking you…
where is Ethiopia’s flag?…
you better leave Eritreans’ problem to Eritreans and answer the crying girl’s question.
Go behind Eritrean for your crimes cannot save you from responsibilities of human trafficing and selling the young flesh alive for your EFFORT is double crime:)

01/17/12 @ 04:12
Comment from: Brook [Visitor]
Brook

Addis Zemean IF you are not behaving I am going to call Ahmara Princess!

01/17/12 @ 04:35
Comment from: Bethihu [Visitor]
Bethihu

Ethiopia should stop giving away children under the adaptation program, and sending our young sisters to Arab countries where they face untold abuses. Let’s have a tv program in Ethiopia that will help to educate our society about the realty of our sisters facing in the AREB countries….

God bless the wold!!

01/17/12 @ 13:31
Comment from: Bethihu [Visitor]
Bethihu

TEDDY, you don’t deserve the name you are using here to cry and to preach your pointless arguments. Nonstop crybaby would perfectly match to your carctor. What is your purpose?!? Are you one of the Amiches that went crazy, after you found it out the empty promises Isayas Afewerki?! No matter who you are or what caused to be like this, you need help bro!

You just reviling to all here that you are mad who have no positive outcome, but annoying mentatly chalenged individual that you think like you concurring the Ethiopia by fooling
yourself in here…SIDET LEWISHET YAMECHAL belewal
hizbachin…

However, Meles is the greatest leader who is well respected for his hard work and bravery by the majority of the Ethiopian people and your & co corocodial haterate daily cry will not affect him from serving the Ethiopian people….

Gemelu Yehedal, wishaw yechohal!!!!!

Under the wise - smart EPRDF leadership, ethiopia will move
forward with all aspect of developments!!

God bless the wold!!

01/17/12 @ 19:08
Comment from: Shameful [Visitor]
Shameful

@ Betihu,
Gemelu yhedal?LoL
Give it up this is Eritrea’s copyright:)
You people are born to cheat.No creativity hehehe

01/18/12 @ 16:38
Comment from: WHICH ETHIOPIAN FLAG? [Visitor]
WHICH  ETHIOPIAN FLAG?

THE WRITER ASKED “Where is Ethiopia’s flag?”

I WILL ANSWER THESE QUESTION WITH A QUESTION : WHICH FLAG?? Ethiopia nowadays has got numbers of flags, is it woyane flag? Haileselassie flag or whoelse?

01/18/12 @ 17:35
Comment from: Bethihu [Visitor]
Bethihu

@shameful the floosh…Gemelu Yehedal…LOL.

Did you got that proverb from your Italian masters as well? If that is the case, you might be right. Otherwise, there is no such a an Eretrian proverbs, because you use to belong to us….You are funny though..

God bless the world!!

01/19/12 @ 03:49
Comment from: mesfin_b [Member]  
mesfin_b

Did any one of you meles the “Stinking dog” cadres see the news bite in the video?
The young Ethiopian lady was telling her remorse without hesitation. She was so emotional to the point that she was chocked with tears. yet you “meles baboons” still worship your Ag** F**** Shifta leader as if he is not the culprit ?
You guys are more idiot than the amoeba. dirtier than dung fly.
Your final ደመውዝ ought to be በንዚን አርከፍክፎ ማንጨርጨር ነው ::
ሞት ለ ሌባው መለስና አዜብ
ሞት ለ እ ህ አ ደ ግ አጫፋሪዎች ሁሉ

01/19/12 @ 21:02

rebtel

advertisements

The views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of nazret.com. The views are solely that of the author. Become a blogger of nazret.com, the #1 Rated Ethiopian Website according to Alexa. Contact us for details

Search

  XML Feeds

powered by b2evolution
© nazret.com The Most Popular Ethiopian Website. nazret is Ranked #1 by Alexa and Qantcast.
All Rights Reserved 1994-2014
About Us | Contact | Feedback | Help | Privacy | Terms and Conditions